Good morning,
We learned some big news yesterday: following a joint letter from Act on Mass and other groups, the Legislature’s Joint Committee on Rules will host a public hearing on the Legislative rules next Tuesday. That means that we, the public, have the opportunity to provide feedback and suggestions about how the Legislature conducts business—at the very seat of power itself.
We know that transparency and accountability in our state house matters to Bay Staters (just ask the 86% who favor subjecting them to public records law!). And we know that the legislative rules are one of the most important pressure points we have to change how the Legislature conducts itself. It’s why we’re gearing up to push for rules changes in January with the Every District Accountable campaign. And it’s why this hearing is a crucial moment to have our voices heard.
Our movement fought long and hard to get the rules reforms passed last year. According to legislative leaders, the 2025 Rules Package was a response to that public demand, intended to improve both transparency and efficiency. The reforms they passed included some major transparency wins, as well as some setbacks and loopholes. In the year-and-change since then, we have seen the new reforms fuel people power, while loopholes and inconsistent compliance continue to obscure crucial information.
We’ve also failed to see much efficiency. And with just seven weeks left in this legislative session, it seems like at least one leader is having regrets: Senate President Spilka said in a statement this week that the legislature’s pile of unfinished legislation is “unacceptable,” decrying their “prolonged inaction on many of the major bills currently in conference as residents face rising energy bills and an ongoing housing crisis.”
(Sharing Spilka’s comments, one Boston Globe reporter joked: “We’re all trying to find the guys who did this!”)
Here’s what I think: we shouldn’t let Senate President Spilka (!) have the last word on public critiques of legislative inaction and the consequences of their convoluted process!
The hearing will be held next Tuesday, November 17th at 1 pm at the state house, with in-person, virtual, and written testimony (details here). We’re asking you—our allies, friends, volunteers, and supporters—to help us make a statement to the Legislature that in the midst of rising energy bills, a hostile federal administration, municipal budget shortages, and an ongoing housing crisis, we deserve better than the bare minimum. We need rules reforms to build on last year’s wins, correct loopholes and noncompliance, and codify even better protections for transparency and accountability.
Can you join us by signing up to testify in-person, virtually, or submitting written testimony? We’ve made it easy for you with a one-stop-shop Joint Rules Testimony Toolkit, which offers instructions for signing up, testimony guidelines, and sample testimony.

State House Scoop
Legislature’s rule-breaking gets in the way of Saturday Scoop writing
What do they say about best laid plans?
You make them, and then the state legislature that you monitor for a living decides to host a hearing on their broken rules process in just 4 days time? Violating the 10-day notice requirement for public hearings in said rules? That’s how the saying goes, right?
Here’s what I wanted to write this week’s Saturday Scoop about: we have 52 days left in this legislative session. Winter is right around the corner, and food and energy prices are higher than ever. Devastating federal cuts are about to hit Medicaid, Medicare, and SNAP. When the Legislature ended formal sessions on July 31st, there were 12 major bills in conference committee negotiations. 105 days later, we have 12 major bills in conference committee negotiations. Some of these bills, including the gargantuan “economic development” bill, contains dozens of individual policy decisions themselves. There is no public insight into the negotiations. Nothing has moved.
The Commonwealth Beacon released a helpful tracker of the individual policy decisions still outstanding at this point, which I recommend perusing: “Election season is done. Holiday season is approaching. And lawmakers still have dozens of big decisions to make.” From energy affordability, to pet welfare, to betting machines, to cell phones in schools, to primary care funding, they document more than 40 outstanding policy decisions yet to be resolved.
Looking at all these policies currently under negotiation, it’s a reminder of how undemocratic the “conference committee” process is. Since these policies are part of bills that were passed by both House and Senate, in different versions, their final outcome will be determined by these committees of just six people, who are handpicked by leadership. Their meetings and progress are not made public—your own representative may not know more than you about their progress. Once the committee decide on a final version, it can no longer be amended by rank-and-file reps. And as more and more lawmaking is done through massive omnibus bills, more legislation ends up being ultimately decided by these undemocratic committees.
To change this practice, we would need to change the Legislature’s rules. That’s why rules advocacy—like Act on Mass’ People’s House Campaign, like our upcoming Every District Accountable campaign, and like Tuesday’s hearing are so important.
It’s also why we pushed legislative leaders to host this hearing. At this point in the year, it seemed like the Legislature had forgotten that they included a requirement in the new rules to host a public hearing on the rules! On Thursday, Act on Mass sent a joint letter with progressive allies including Mass-Care, Progressive Mass, Progressive Democrats of Massachusetts, and Sierra Club Massachusetts, reminding legislative leaders of their commitment to host a hearing and asking for an update. Less than 24 hours later, we were informed that the hearing is scheduled for Tuesday. Legislators were also notified yesterday morning.
This scramble to prepare materials and arrange testimony is exactly what the new joint rules were intended to avoid, with a requirement for a 10-day notice for public hearings. I look forward to reminding them of that at Tuesday’s hearing. So, instead of reading my thoughts about legislative inaction and the opacity of conference committees in a Saturday Scoop, I’ll ask you to tune in to Tuesday’s hearing and listen to me give them out loud. Perhaps, you can take the opportunity to share your own thoughts about how the legislative rules could better serve you, your fellow constituents, and the health of our democracy.
We’ve fought for rules changes before, and won. Here are our top priorities going into Tuesday’s rules hearing:
- Consistent enforcement of existing reforms, including 10-day hearing notice
- Closing the committee vote loophole: we want fully public committee votes
- Restoring the July 31 deadline to prevent lame-duck lawmaking
- Check out our testimony toolkit for more!
What are your top priorities for rules reform? I hope to hear them on Tuesday!
| Missed a Scoop or two? You can find a full archive of all past Saturday Scoops on our blog. |
What else we’re reading this week
Interesting writing and reporting from around the Bay State this week!
- OPINION: The House bid to expand gambling is not just a bad idea. It’s a stealthy move that underscores what the public hates about the Legislature. in the Commonwealth Beacon
- How Trump’s War on Offshore Wind Upended a “Limitless” Future for Thousands of New England Workers in ProPublica
- Massachusetts families’ healthcare costs top $34,000, more than housing in most of the state by State House News
- With mom in ICE custody, a Massachusetts stepdad steps up by Simón Rios for WBUR
Oscar’s Outlook: Voters Rejected Question 3. They did Not Reject Electoral Reform.
By Act on Mass intern and endorsement committee member Oscar Gillette!
This August, the Yes on 3 campaign, which was a private equity funded effort to bring regressive electoral reform to Massachusetts, was ahead by 19 points in the polls. Their campaign outraised the opposition campaign by about 25 to 1. Despite these difficulties, the No On 3 campaign built a massive coalition of unions, elected officials, and local activists (including Act on Mass!) to defeat Question 3. In the end, it wasn’t even close: the “No” campaign won by 22 points, winning every city and town except for one.

A 41% shift from August to November towards a position whose campaign was wildly outraised does not happen every day. This speaks to a campaign that was run excellently, and to the importance of the “intangibles.” The No on 3 campaign didn’t have money for big TV ads. It was built on a massive coalition of endorsers spreading the message through their own channels. Their message is what swung the electorate by 41 points. Interestingly, the No campaign also managed to do so without opposing electoral reform in general: No on 3 and its endorsers constantly re-iterated their support for Ranked Choice Voting.
It might be tempting to argue that Question 3 underperformed because conservative voters are skeptical of voter reform. However, the communities that rejected Question 3 the hardest voted along progressive lines on the other initiatives. Nine of the ten communities that voted hardest for No on 3 also voted Yes on 9 (to maintain a gun control law) by over 65%. Similarly, 9 out of those 10 communities voted No on 5 (to reject tax cuts). Overall, among those same ten communities, 72% of votes were against question 5, making up nearly the entire margin by which question 5 was defeated. In other words, this question was killed by progressive voters who saw through it, not just by conservative voters who distrust change. Interestingly, two of the ten communities that rejected Q3 by the biggest proportions have also passed a ranked choice voting home rule petition. This was not a rejection of electoral reform: it was a redirection.
Both the Yes on 3 campaigns and the No on 3 campaigns supported ranked choice voting, and both the yes side and the no sides’ messaging reflects that they were appealing to voters who support Ranked Choice Voting.
The No sides’ success shows what the progressive movement space in Massachusetts can accomplish with very little financial resources: just coordinated messaging, skilled communicators, and progressive validators. Combining that ability with the dedicated activism displayed by some of the Yes on 3 campaigners who also support ranked choice voting, I think the supporters of these campaigns who just fought a hard fight can form a dream team to bring about ranked choice voting in our partisan primaries and our general elections. The No on 3 campaign’s progressive messaging swung the electorate by 41 points, and the Yes on 3 campaign got 39% of the vote. This referendum displayed an appetite for electoral reform, and a progressive desire to see that electoral reform be grounded in real academic research regarding voter behavior.
Six years ago, Ranked Choice Voting failed by less than 10%. That No campaign had the endorsement of then Governor Charlie Baker; ranked choice voting now has the support of governor Maura Healey. Since then eight communities have passed home rule petitions seeking to enact Ranked Choice. Since then, Maine and New York City have had high profile elections using Ranked Choice Voting. A consensus has since been built (thanks to the hard work of the good people at Voter Choice Massachusetts) that makes a win on RCV now possible. Knowing that the electorate can be moved considerably on electoral reform issues by effective communication and progressive validators, that 10% margin from six years ago seems very beatable right now.
The tactical decision to pursue a statewide ballot initiative or to continue getting home rule petitions and fighting for a local option is not Act On Mass’ decision to make. Regardless of the approach taken by Voter Choice Massachusetts and the RCV coalition, the muscle displayed by the No on 3 campaign and the dedication shown by some activists in the Yes on 3 campaign should be directed towards the Ranked Choice Voting movement. Now is the time for us to put our energy where our messaging was, and support Ranked Choice Voting.
Take Action
Join our climate allies to canvass for Mass Save! – Sunday 11/15, 1 pm

Our climate allies at Mass Power Forward are taking their fight to protect energy efficiency straight to the heart of the district of House Energy Chair Mark Cusack. Help them show people power in Braintree on Sunday!
Testify at the Rules Hearing on Tuesday! – 11/17, 1 pm at the state house

Make sure your voice is heard about the changes in this year’s legislative rules, and the reforms you want to see going forward!
What’s Left in the Legislative Session? – 11/18, 7 pm

Our allies at Progressive Mass are hosting a webinar next week to review the outstanding policies still to go this session. Act on Mass will also join to talk about defending Question 1 against legislative interference. Join us!
Thanks for reading and for supporting Act on Mass! Have a great weekend.
Scotia
Scotia Hille (she/her)
Executive Director, Act on Mass

